Customer Testimonials

Leave a Review!


Customer Testimonials

5 Stars

I dealt with Cassandra and she was nice and knowledgeable. I would recommend Cassandra to everyone I know. Very helpful.


- Brittany Noggler
Fort recovery Ohio , AL

5 Stars

Price is satisfactory and the service is great. I would recommend this company for reasonable price for low income people, best for safe drivers and and cheap for the great start.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Suresh
From Harrisburg

5 Stars

Friendly and knowledgeable staff, i wold like to recommend this place to all of you out their who wants to learn more about coverage an how it helps you in what type of situation.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Anonymous
From Harrisburg

5 Stars

Great people and great service!
April 23, 2019

McMillan insurance agency is top notch when it comes to customer service. I sell cars for living and have seen first hand how difficult it is for my customers to get insurance sometimes. I call Lisa Williams and get them set up and they can take delivery of their vehicles same day! If you want great service, give them a call!
I would recommend to a friend.

- Gboards999

5 Stars

Great Customer Service
August 18, 2019

I found this agency on the internet, and since I was purchasing in the area, called. My call was answered by Alex who went above and beyond to find the right policy for me. Our transaction was complicated, but she kept on trying to find affordable options. Thanks for all of your hard work, Alex! This type of service makes you a customer for life.
I would recommend to a friend.

- KarenPA
From New Mexico

5 Stars

April 4, 2019

As a Realtor I recommend my clients get a quote from Mcmillan Insurance. Often times beating the level of coverage and price of their current provider. Mcmillan Insurance offers great products with unmatched customer service. I personally Have all my policies with Mcmillan.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Serg
From York pa

5 Stars

March 22, 2019

I would just like to take the time to express how grateful I am to have an agent such as Lisa! Not only has she always gone above & beyond to ensure I had the best suited policy, she has extended a listening ear when I simply just needed to vent. Her ability to make you feel that you are being handled w/ care goes a very long way. Thank you for all you've done for me!
I would recommend to a friend.

- EMichelle
From Rockville, MD

5 Stars

Highly Recommended
November 2, 2018

I was recommended by Apple Nissan of York and I’m so glad I was. Lisa is very accommodating me with all my needs as a lower income disabled person, I had limitations and she was able to find me a great policy at my price point. I never had any trouble getting though to her and feel there’s nothing she isn’t willing to help me with in my insurance policy. Thanks for caring.
I would recommend to a friend.

- KathyO
From York pa

5 Stars

LISA IS AMAZINg!!
May 1, 2018

No stress, no hassle, very prompt and accurate information provided. Lisa handled it all and I was able to lower my insurance by $80 with my new vehicle purchase.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Rashanda
From Harrisburg, Pa

5 Stars

Look no further!
March 20, 2018

The McMillan Ageny always provides excellent customer service. They have an extremely friendly staff who are always very knowledgeable, reliable, and eager to address all of my insurance needs.
I would recommend to a friend.

- NickM
From Harrisburg, Pa

5 Stars

Lisa is prompt and personable
March 8, 2018

Lisa Williams was recommend to me from a friend, and she did an amazing job. I contacted her for a quote on My car insurance. During our initial conversation I could tell she was very attentive to what I was saying and very knowledgeable in her responses. She was very personable through the entire conversation, she made me feel very comfortable. Lisa then got back to me promptly goong over in detail my coverage snd prices. Thank you for making my experience in shopping for insurance hassle free and all around nice
I would recommend to a friend.

- CurtisV
From Littlestown

5 Stars

Great service
March 8, 2018

When ever I have a question or a problem Lisa is right there for it. She goes above and beyond to make sure the outcome is good and explains in detail for me. Lisa helped my daughter when she had an accident and even asked if she was ok or needed anything before even going on about the claim. I've never had an insurance company treat me like I was a person rather then a number. I have had others help me in the office also and they have treated me the same way. I get offers from other insurance companies all the time wanting me to let them have a chance to lower my insurance but I won't be going anywhere else even if it would be lower.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Bear2073
From glen rock

5 Stars

Industry standard setting professionalism
March 15, 2017

Simply put, he and his staff embody and exmpify the true essence of professionalism, customer service, and results. I have been working with Mr. McMillan since 2012 and nomatter what time zone I am in, he delivers superbly.
I would recommend to a friend.

- MrGibs
From PA

5 Stars

Recommended by a friend
May 29, 2016

I made a post on Facebook that I was unhappy with my insurance company. Someone recommended McMillan Agency, so I contacted Lester on Facebook. He helped with all of my questions, got me better coverage then my last agent and for less than what I paid and that was with getting life insurance, too. He covered my wife’s wedding ring and everything was still less than what I paid before. Pretty pleased with the process and I look forward to having Lester as my agent. Finally facebook was good for something.
I would recommend to a friend.

- PleasedCustomer9
From Harrisburg, PA

5 Stars

Lester went above and beyond for me!
May 3, 2016

I am a high maintenance customer and so I just needed to put a shout out on here letting the world know that Lester McMillan is a really awesome agent to have on your side! Though I call in frequently and have lots of questions, Lester is always kind, courteous and gets back to me right away if he can't answer me right on the spot. I would recommend him to anyone if you want great service. Thanks, Lester!
I would recommend to a friend.

- WendyG
From Biglerville, PA

5 Stars

Excellent customer service and fast!!
April 15, 2015

Lester Mcmillan serves excellence customer service throughout this ordeal of me switching from my old insurance company to "Mcmillan Insurance Agency" . He is fast and efficient with getting back to me and is very knowlegeable in his products! He was able to get me low rates and great service. Its a one stop shop and Mr. Mcmillan will do anything to serve his customers and make you happy! The staff also serves excellence in customer service. He delivers what he promised!! Very pleased an happy customer!!
I would recommend to a friend.

- ssanh
From York PA

5 Stars

Two thumbs up!
November 16, 2014

Working with Mcmillan agency was a great experience. I was able to increase my coverages and save money at the same time. The staff here is extremely professional and always available. What more could you ask for.

- AMitch
From York PA

5 Stars

Great Agency
November 12, 2014

The Lester McMillan Agency has been a really professional and prompt insurance agency. Their office was able to provide me with top notch service and saved me $1,000s of dollars a year on auto, home owners, renters and life insurance policies. The McMillan agency was able to inform and educate me regarding policy specific details and specifics regarding my coverage. The McMillan agency was also able to provide me with professional service with honesty. I have and will continue to recommend the Lester McMillan Agency to friends, family and business associates for their insurance needs. I am in the real estate business and have been able to utilize the services of the Lester McMillan Agency for clients and other business and personal insurance needs. Wonderful staff and willing to go the extra mile for their costumers.

- Carmela
From Dallastown, PA

5 Stars

Lester McMillan Recommendation
November 12, 2014

The Lester McMillan Agency has been a really professional and prompt insurance agency. Their office was able to provider me with top notch service and saved me $1,000s of dollars a year on auto, home owners, renters and life insurance policies. The McMillan agency was able to inform and educate me regarding policy specific details and specifics regarding my coverage. The McMillan agency was also able to provide me with professional service with honesty. I have and will continue to recommend the Lester McMillan Agency to friends, family and business associates for their insurance needs. I am in the real estate business and have been able to utilize the services of the Lester McMillan Agency for clients and other business and personal insurance needs. Wonderful staff and willing to go the extra mile for their costumers.

- Terrence
From York, PA

5 Stars

Lester was great!
November 5, 2014

I had such a great experience dealing with Lester. I heard from a friend that he could save me money on car insurance. He was really flexible meeting with me when I was available. I ended up switching all my insurances to Nationwide. The whole experience was easy and enjoyable. I love that I can call him with a question and he gets back to me with an answer right away. I recommend him to anyone who is looking to save money and have an honest person to deal with.
I would recommend to a friend.

- Lisa102313
From Seven Valleys, PA

Featured Carriers

See more

  • American Modern Slide
  • amtrust
  • Bristol West
  • Encompass
  • Foremost
  • Grange Insurance
  • national-general
  • nationwide-insurance
  • Openly
  • Plymouth Rock Assurance
  • progressive
  • Safeco
  • state-auto
  • The Farmers Fire Insurance Company
  • Travelers Insurance
  • universal
  • usli